Talk:Critical appraisal: Is Reconciliation Possible?
From Reconciling understandings of Scripture and Science
Jump to navigationJump to search
[discussion moved here from page Critical appraisal: Is Reconciliation Possible? ]
User:Colin wrote: Critical Appraisal on question "Is Reconciliation Possible?" - Not sure about this setup.
User:Bruce replies:
- The reason Template:NewTopic (q.v.) says that another editor should go on to this step is so that the correct classification of the new topic as a Problem, Question or Reconciliation Challenge can be confirmed or discussed if necessary.
- In this case I'll wind it back a bit and assume that we agree that it's as described above, ('question "Is Reconciliation Possible?"') — clearly a question, not a problem. So I'm inserting it as such and re-classifying it at Current Topics for Consideration — if that's not acceptable, please discuss here. Note that if reworded as a problem it might overlap the existing Problem "Disputed Authority of Science" which has been waiting for discussion since July.
- User:Bruce continues:
- Having done that, I think it still needs to be reworded, whether as a question or (maybe) a problem distinct from the Authority of Science problem.
